/agents
← Case studiesCase 01 / 03

Checkout, re-thought

Quote to order, without the leak.

MakerVerse · B2B manufacturing marketplace
Lead Product Designer · 2025

~1.5×quote-to-order conversion
~2×orders per week
~2.6×order-entry revenue
~17weeks held

Every figure is relative or indexed, out of professional discretion regarding a former employer.

The Place Order page, as shipped
(01)

Context

MakerVerse is a B2B manufacturing marketplace. A customer uploads a CAD part, receives an instant auto-quote, and can place the order online. Auto-quote coverage had climbed to roughly 80% of transactions. But only about one in five people who saw a price actually ordered.

A price-seen is demand you have already paid to acquire and already priced. It is the cheapest revenue in the business to recover.

(02)

Question

Could we convert the people who had already said yes to the price, without touching the pricing engine?

(03)

Diagnosis

Indexed to price-seen = 100, about 68 entered checkout but only about 20 placed an order. The biggest drop was not at the quote. People liked the price; they fell out inside checkout.

Checkout step funnel · before the redesign4-step funnel · 1 Jan – 19 Jun 2025 · Overall 19.59%
100%checkout entry

1 Shipping & Billing page

38.27%38.3% of entry

2 Review-order page

51.19%19.6% of entry

3 Place order

100%19.6% of entry

4 Order confirmation

≈ 6 in 10 left on the Shipping & Billing accordion page

Mixpanel page views (Prod-CP) · unique users · 30-day window · step % = conversion from previous step · accordion-section opens were not tracked · relative only

The checkout step funnel before the redesign (relative only)

Session recordings showed people bouncing between the shipping, billing and checkout steps: hesitation and back-tracking, not a hard technical block.

Three hypotheses
(H1)

The CTA was scaring people. “Proceed to checkout” reads like “pay now”.

(H2)

There was no reason to act now.

(H3)

The flow was simply too long.

Heatmaps of the quote page CTAs
(04)

Decision

The obvious move was a big redesign. I didn’t take it. If I changed everything at once I’d never know which change actually worked.

Three phases, cheapest to most invasive
(Phase 1)

A CTA A/B test.

Design
(Phase 2)

A time-boxed discount.

Pricing
(Phase 3)

Four checkout steps cut to two.

Design

Keep design and pricing separable.

Phase 1 · CTA A/B testcta_conversion_rate_event · total events per day · 14 – 21 May
B · Review your Quote · average 147.1A · Proceed to checkout · average 87.8
050100150200May 14May 15May 16May 17May 18May 19May 20May 21
Phase 1, the A/B read: “Review your Quote” against “Proceed to checkout”
Removing the extra check pages
Before · four stepsAfter · two steps
1Price
2Shipping /
Billing
3Checkout
42Place Order
(05)

Delivery

Four steps became two: Price → Place Order. Nothing important was dropped; it was consolidated.

  • Full price up front, net and gross.
  • Shipping country defaulted by location, with an obvious edit.
  • VAT-ID asked once.
  • One binding Quotation PDF, its download demoted to a small icon.
The Price page, as shipped
The Place Order page, as shipped

It shipped across several sprints with a real team. I logged roughly a dozen UAT issues against the Figma source of truth before release.

(06)

Impact

Quote-to-order conversion went from about one in five to about one in three. Orders per week roughly doubled, and order-entry revenue was about 2.6×. It held for around 17 weeks, so it wasn’t a launch spike.

Held for ~17 weeks: a sustained lift, not a launch spikeQuote→order conversion (indexed, wk0 = 100)
100125150wk 0wk 17 P1 · CTA A/BP2 · discountP3 · flow cut baseline variance (pooled multi-week avg) ~1-in-5 → ~1-in-3
(≈1.5× conversion)

Illustrative index · relative only · phase timing schematic

Quote-to-order conversion, indexed to the pre-period baseline (illustrative, relative only)

Phase 1 and Phase 3 I attribute to design with confidence. Phase 2 was a pricing lever: I flag it, I don’t claim it.

(07)

Reflection

Next time I’d run a persistent hold-out control across all three phases, and lock the baseline windows up front.

The detailed artefacts are available on request

Request the full case study

Next caseEvaa