/agents
← Case studiesCase 03 / 03

The sign-up wall, removed

Let them in first, verify later.

MakerVerse · B2B manufacturing marketplace
Lead Product Designer · 2025

+41%sign-up volume, in one sprint
19%→24%sign-up conversion
~7months held
~€760kpipeline, the value of the leak

Measured before and after, with the effect kept separate, not as a clean A/B test.

The shorter sign-up, as shipped
(01)

Context

On MakerVerse a customer uploads a CAD part, gets an instant auto-quote and can order online. But saving a quote or placing an order sat behind a sign-up. I owned the registration funnel: everything between a visitor arriving and a usable account.

Someone who uploads a part has shown more intent than any ad click. The leak was worth about €760k in pipeline.

(02)

Question

Could we keep the people who had just uploaded a part, without buying more traffic?

(03)

Diagnosis

About 72% of people who uploaded a part dropped before they got through sign-up. The leak sat right after the highest-intent action on the site.

Three signals
(Mixpanel)

The funnel isolated the leak to the sign-up step, not the quote or the upload.

(Hotjar)

Recordings showed people stalling at account creation.

(Sales)

Two mandatory fields had no use downstream.

The sign-up gate, mapped
Hotjar heatmap

Upload-led sign-up converted about 10× better than the standalone “Sign up” button, so the fix belonged on the upload path.

(04)

Decision

The wall was premature, not necessary. I chose the cheapest credible fix: fewer fields, and email verification moved to the order.

SSO and passkeys promised bigger lifts, but they were multi-sprint builds; I kept them on the roadmap. Progressive access shipped in one sprint, was easy to reverse, and isolated one change so the result could be read.

Before the build, I flagged the risk of deferring verification in writing.

The form, before and after
Before · verify at the doorAfter · verify at the order
1Upload
2Sign-up
3Quote
4Place Order
(05)

Delivery

  • Two fields cut that Sales confirmed weren’t needed.
  • Email verification moved from sign-up to Place Order: unverified users can upload, quote and explore.
  • Billing, VAT and address captured in context at the order step.
  • Mixpanel events defined so the move could be measured.
The shorter sign-up form
Verification, now at the order
Billing in context
Place Order, as shipped
Form specs for handoff

I wrote the proposal, recorded a Loom walkthrough and built a clickable Figma prototype; a partner engineering team built it.

(06)

Impact

Sign-up volume rose 41% in one sprint, and sign-up conversion went from 19% to 24%. It held for about seven months, so it wasn’t a launch spike.

(07)

Reflection

The win was real, and it created the debt I’d predicted.

Password reset broke for accounts that had never been verified, and unverified access invited throwaway accounts; the team later capped them at 5 open transactions. Next time I’d ship the guardrails with the friction removal, and run a persistent hold-out control.

The verification redirect

A deferred wall doesn’t disappear. It relocates.

The detailed artefacts are available on request

Request the full case study

Next caseCheckout Optimisation